Dostoevsky

The Grand Inquisitor

Ivan Karamazov tells his younger brother Alyosha the well-known parable "The Grand Inquisitor" in Fyodor Dostoevsky's The Brothers Karamazov. It examines the deep conflicts between freedom and authority and is set in 16th-century Seville during the Spanish Inquisition. 

The Return of Christ is one of the main narratives and arguments. Jesus comes back to earth and works miracles, like raising a dead child. The crowd instantly recognizes him, but the 90-year-old Grand Inquisitor orders his arrest.

The Inquisitor's Indictment: The Inquisitor makes the case in a lengthy monologue that the Church's work is hampered by Christ's return. He contends that by granting people the freedom of choice—a burden that the weak majority cannot bear—Christ overestimated human nature.

The Three Temptations: The Inquisitor uses Christ's three desert temptations as the foundation for his criticism.

Bread (Materialism): People prefer security and "earthly bread" over "heavenly bread"; Christ ought to have transformed stones into bread.

Miracles (Certainty): The Inquisitor contends that people require miracles to maintain their faith, but Christ declined to perform a miracle to demonstrate His divinity.

Power (Authority): By using Caesar's sword to establish a stable, "happy" order for the masses, the Church has "corrected" Christ's rejection of earthly rule.

Christ doesn't say anything during the speech. He merely gives the Inquisitor a "bloodless lips" kiss at the conclusion. The astonished Inquisitor lets him go but orders him never to come back.

- The Brothers Karamazov by Fyodor Dostoevsky

The End of the World

On the Beach 

by Nevil Shute

“It's not the end of the world at all," he said. "It's only the end for us. The world will go on just the same, only we shan't be in it. I dare say it will get along all right without us.”

― Nevil Shute, On the Beach

The post-nuclear holocaust future portrayed in this book hasn't yet come to pass in the real world. The survivors' actions, feelings, and fears are expertly portrayed by the author. Suspense is created by the activities of a submarine commander and the continuous search for evidence of life in the northern hemisphere. This Australian setting masterfully captures the real lives of those survivors while they wait for the arrival of the nuclear cloud. This book still challenges you to think about the possibility of nuclear annihilation. Commander Dwight Towers, an American submarine captain, clings to the illusion that his family in Connecticut is still alive, even purchasing gifts for a homecoming he knows will never occur. Shute focuses on how common people interpret the unimaginable through a "stiff-upper-lip" lens. When radiation sickness strikes Moira Davidson, a young woman who first attempts to drown her despair in alcohol before developing a close, platonic bond with Towers, Peter and Mary Holmes, a young Australian couple, struggle to maintain normalcy for their infant daughter while debating the agonizing necessity of euthanizing her.
A scientist named John Osborne spends his last months racing a Ferrari in the final Australian Grand Prix, a dream he has had all his life.

The story's "Slow Burn" Effect has a subdued, objective tone. This eerie calm and the characters' insistence on caring for gardens they will never see bloom are exactly what make the absence of "action" or "rioting" gradually transform into a horror. I found the story to be emotionally compelling.

View all my reviews

Two Lives

Twist 

by Colum McCann

“Not a single atom in our bodies today was there when we were children. Every bit of us has been replaced many times over. We flake away and become new. Whatever we are now, we are not the stuff from which we were originally made. All the people we once were. All the people we had once hoped to be.”

― Colum McCann, Twist

An authentic story of two lives—that of a diver and a writer—whose paths cross in a world where one gets "all of the truth but none of the honesty"—an adventure story worthy of Joseph Conrad, but more. I was slowly but surely enthralled by journalist Fennel's elegy of a real, creative, and beautiful person named John A. Conway. As a reader who values good writing, this book captured my attention in a manner I don't often experience. In the realm of imagination that leads one down unexpected but ultimately familiar paths, on the sea, and at the edge of existence, humanity is amazed. I think this might be the best book I've read this year.

Anthony Fennell, a struggling Irish journalist, is the protagonist of the story. He was given the task of writing a profile on the crews that fix the enormous underwater fiber-optic cables that transport digital data around the globe. Fennell develops an obsession with the mission's leader, the mysterious diver and engineer John Conway, while on board the repair ship Georges Lecointe off the coast of West Africa.

The irony that people can still be incredibly lonely in a "hyper-connected" world is examined in the book. Apocalypse Now by Francis Ford Coppola and Joseph Conrad's Heart of Darkness share many similarities. However, the storyline includes aspects of environmental activism and the susceptibility of global infrastructure to sabotage.

View all my reviews

Dense Parable

The Sibyl 

by Pär Lagerkvist

“Nothing is more foreign than the world of one's childhood when one has truly left it.”

― Pär Lagerkvist, The Sibyl

Pär Lagerkvist’s The Sibyl is a dense, poetic parable that explores the "inhuman" and "capricious" nature of the divine. The novel, written by the 1951 Nobel Prize winner, is noted for its spare but lyrical style and its unsettling comparison between Christian and pagan concepts of God.

The story follows Ahasuerus (the Wandering Jew), who is cursed by Jesus to eternal life without rest, and an aging Sibyl (a former Pythia of Delphi) who lives in disgrace in the mountains. Unlike traditional portrayals of a compassionate deity, Lagerkvist’s God is described by the characters as "alien," "repellent," and "wild as lightning." The Sibyl views her service to Apollo as a form of "ecstasy" that was ultimately a "betrayal" of her humanity.

A central and mysterious figure is the Sibyl's son, a mute, mentally disabled man with a perpetual "enigmatic smile". Reviews often interpret him as a "meaningless" but "divine" mirror of God—a paradoxical being who is both "matter" and "consciousness." I found the "lucid simplicity" of the narrative and its "heightened, surging lyricism" appealing and fitting for the parable-like story.

While some find the book "scathing" or "depressing" because it rejects the idea of a comforting faith, suggesting instead that "fate will be forever bound up with god" regardless of one's actions, I did not experience the narrative in that way. It is often grouped with Lagerkvist’s other "god-struck" novels like Barabbas and my favorite Dwarf, for its focus on isolation, guilt, and the "futility of life without loyalty to God".

View all my reviews

Evil

The Exorcist 

by William Peter Blatty

“Perhaps evil is the crucible of goodness... and perhaps even Satan - Satan, in spite of himself - somehow serves to work out the will of God.”

― William Peter Blatty, The Exorcist

This book, in my opinion, is a "slow descent into hell," with a steady tempo that creates fear through scientific and clinical research before the supernatural aspects take over. One of the main strengths is the characters. Chris MacNeil is a compelling, desperate mother, and Father Karras shows a relatable struggle between faith and science. The philosophical queries raised in the book concerning the existence of God and the nature of evil are terrifying. Many readers may find the novel's graphic depictions upsetting and offensive, and it is intentionally raw and profane. Detective Kinderman offers a much-needed respite from the stress. Overall, I liked the novel's theological and philosophical elements as well as the tension that underpins the plot's development.

View all my reviews

Climate Change

Impasse: Climate Change and the Limits of Progress 

by Roy Scranton

This is a searing investigation of the state of the world vis a vis climate change. It details information and opinions that suggest we have reached an important moment that will determine what happens to the world in the not too distant future. The author's central argument is that our "dogmatic faith in progress" is the primary obstacle to addressing climate catastrophe. He contends that the "impasse" we face is not just political, but existential and cognitive—our brains and narratives are fundamentally unequipped to grasp the scale of the crisis.

View all my reviews 

Human Art

 

Art of Humanism 

by Kenneth M. Clark

“Ruskin said: ‘Great nations write their autobiographies in three manuscripts, the book of their deeds, the book of their words and the book of their art. - Kenneth Clark






Kenneth Clark's 1983 book The Art of Humanism is a succinct examination of the Italian Renaissance of the fifteenth century from a humanistic perspective. Clark, who is most known for his seminal series Civilization, explores how the visual arts were transformed by a renewed sense of human greatness and potential. The book focuses on five major masters of the era: Andrea Mantegna: Classical antiquity and the heroic figure; Paolo Uccello: The compulsive, scientific study of perspective; Donatello: Human emotion and drama in sculpture; and Leon Battista Alberti: Architecture and the mathematical foundation of beauty.
Sandro Botticelli: Humanism's poetic and spiritual side.

"Belief in the greatness of man and the supremacy of human values" is how Clark characterizes humanism. He contends that these artists were philosophers who gave these new ideals shape in addition to being expert craftsmen. Clark's "patrician self-confidence" and "great man" approach to art history, which emphasizes individual brilliance over larger social movements, are frequently highlighted in reviews of his larger body of work. In keeping with that model, this book offers a close-knit, knowledgeable tour of particular masterpieces.

View all my reviews